In August 2022, European gas traded above €300 per megawatt hour, ten times its pre-crisis norm. Energy-intensive businesses failed, and plenty that survived discovered something awkward in the post-mortem: their exposure had been hedgeable all along, and nobody had looked. Others discovered the opposite: the hedge a bank had sold them tracked a reference price that wasn't actually their cost. Commodity risk rewards one skill above all others: knowing which of those two companies you are.

Finding the exposure

Commodity exposure hides deeper than FX. Some is direct: you buy fuel, power, wheat, steel. More is embedded: a haulage contract indexed to diesel, a packaging supplier passing through resin prices, an electricity bill that's really a gas price wearing a costume. The discovery work is walking the P&L line by line asking what price is really underneath this, and it belongs in the exposure inventory alongside currencies and rates.

Hedgeable or not: the honest test

Fuel has liquid, well-behaved reference markets, though the price at the pump contains taxes and margins the market price doesn't, so a hedge covers only part of the move. Steel has multiple reference prices, and not all of them are valid for your grade and geography; hedge the wrong one and you own basis, not protection. Dairy is the cautionary tale: cheese trades globally, but milk prices are stubbornly local, and the correlation between your cost and any tradeable reference may be too weak to hedge at all. The instruments piece and the basis risk piece below take these apart properly.

Not every hedge is a derivative

The commodity toolkit is wider than the financial one. Pass-through clauses move the risk to customers, where the market allows it. Fixed-price supply agreements are hedges in commercial clothing, often the best available instrument for a mid-market buyer. Financial instruments (futures with their daily margin cash flows, average-price swaps, options) come after, for the exposures that survive the commercial fixes. Futures margining deserves respect: a hedge that's right at maturity can still drain cash on the way, which is the Metallgesellschaft lesson from the risk framework hub.

The same job at three sizes

Start-up: No derivatives. The tools are commercial: pass-through pricing where you can, supplier fixes where you can't, and a line in the model showing what a doubling of your key input does to gross margin, so the exposure is at least a known number.

Established mid-market: The first structured approach: exposure mapped, pass-through maximised, fixed-price agreements on the lumpy inputs, and perhaps a simple swap on a genuinely liquid leg like road diesel. The discipline is refusing hedges on references that don't match your cost.

Large corporate: Trading-adjacent capability: basis management, optionality around physical flexibility, dedicated analysts. And the familiar large-company failure: hedging sophistication outrunning the board's understanding of it.